Ask Three Clients Why They Stayed
Get your real positioning language from the clients who already bought.
By James Schramko · Updated May 2026
Your sales page says what you do. Your clients know why they stayed. These are different things. The gap between them is usually where positioning goes fuzzy.
This playbook gives you two tools. The first is a set of questions to send to current clients. The second is the lens you read the answers through. Together they bring out the words your positioning should already use.
How to use this
Pick two or three clients you have worked with for at least a year. Send them the questions below as a direct message, not a form. Keep the language as written.
Tell them up front: you care less about compliments and more about what actually changed. The question is open on purpose. You want honest reflection, not a polished testimonial.
The answers will vary. Some will be short and some will surprise you. You are looking for three things: language that repeats, specifics that land, and moments where the client describes the shift better than you ever have.
The questions
Send this as written. The "we" refers to you and your client.
Looking back over the time we have worked together, where specifically do you think your business, decisions, income, positioning, confidence, or speed would be materially different if we had never worked together?
I am less interested in compliments and more interested in concrete shifts:
- decisions you would have delayed
- mistakes you may have made
- opportunities you would have missed
- introductions or leverage you would not have had
- business model changes
- pricing changes
- confidence changes
- operational simplifications
- strategic clarity
- speed of execution
- transitions you may not have made alone
- personal life or relationship changes that followed from the business shifts or clearer objectives
The more specific the better.
The extraction lens
When the answers come back, read them through this lens. Look for what repeats and what is specific, rather than for lines to quote.
- What was happening before
- What was stuck
- What decisions were difficult
- What changed first
- What decisions became easier
- What relationships mattered
- What introductions mattered
- What would have happened without the work
- Where speed increased
- Where confusion reduced
- What they stopped doing
- What became simpler
- What became clearer
- Where confidence appeared
- Where money improved
- Where stress reduced
- What patterns repeated
What to do with it
Look for three things in the answers.
Language you did not put there. If a client uses a phrase you never used in your marketing, that phrase is probably truer than your sales copy.
Specifics that name the actual pain. Vague praise tells you nothing. Precise language about a precise problem is your positioning.
Patterns across several clients. One comment on its own could be anything. When three clients use similar language, that is your positioning signal.
Rewrite one line of your sales page using client language. Then check whether it describes the right person more clearly than what you had before.